Present: Books and Managing Complexity (with computers)
Date: , Page
©Copyright 1996, Rainer von Königslöw. All rights reserved.
15 York Valley Cr., North York, Ont., M2P 1A8Tel.: (416) 410-2202, Fax: 489-4688
Books and Managing Complexity
Draft: for review only
Rainer von Königslöw
Version 0.1: June 14, 1997
Copyright 1997, All rights reserved.
Diaspora and convergence: the current state of books
Types of books: Books as entities
Company books - business plans, accounts & financial reports, "book keepers"
electronic books, databases as books
lab books - scientific evidence
courts: collecting the paperwork
civil service - managing policy and complexity with written records
advertising, persuasion, hate mongering, misrepresentation
Description - record keeping
Encyclopedias
Reference texts
books of accounts, financial statements
lab notes of experiment results
medical histories
court case evidence reports
architectural & engineering drawings
documentary movies
anthropological - ethnological recordings
Story telling, reporting, persuading, entertaining
novels, romances, legends, children's books
religious legends
movies
Instructions - Constraints
Laws - acts, regulations, bylaws, codes
religious commandments
"how to" books, user guides
listings of computer programs
Hidden books
tables in many databases
files in government archives (not accesible by Freedom of Information, or not known to exist)
some medical record
adoption records
Usage scenarios for books
Application of book-related skills & technologies
accountability, communication, reasoning, public scutiny (sharing)
How much of the moment to moment behaviour is captured by written rules: could we capture and automate the process with expert systems or transaction oriented system?
Accounting
Lists, inventory, order processing, money & balance & value, financial planning & budgets & futures, evaluation of an organization, shares
bank account books (still used for saving accounts)
Management, administration
HR job descriptions
management reports
memos, judgements, evaluations expressed on paper
Science
"publish or perish" -- extend duality with new measurement schemes, new theories, new observations, new experiments, etc.
public documents allowing incrementality, requirement for novelty, review & judgement of peers - juried
justice
legislation, court system, rules of evidence, precedence cases
very much dominated by the paper trail, linking arguments to legislative code, previous documented interpretations, precedence cases
architecture
moving into paper mode with models (pictures) of future views, engineering drawings meeting constraints
medicine
slowly moving into paper mode, but not fully yet
history, tests, images, treatment plan & schedule, prescriptions
billing for small job components & processes, insurance forms, advising & warning patients (clients) to avoid liability
Administration, civil service
managing paper trail, data bases, flow of paper information with forms & lists
inventories, order processing
exception: driving a car
managing a car in complex situations: traffic laws mostly constraints, owner manual covers routine, constraints, exception events
-- usual combination of looking, steering, braking, accelerating -- not covered by book rule -- cannot be automated easily by expert system
exception: politics
not yet govered by paper flow? - (Liberal red book)
primarily argument ad hominem (and ad valorem?)
"vote for me, I am this type of person and have the following general values -- no detailed promises or accountability for past actions
Where we get into more accountability we tend to switch parties -- can't properly compare in power vs out of power candidates or parties; can't compare past actions & promises
Role of writers, publishers, advertisers, ...
Role of schools, other training, ...
schooling through highschool
How much is learning to deal with symbolically expressed information, paperflow
How much is memorizing specific information to actually use later in life exactly as learned - unchanged and unreviewed
How much as learning language skills (including math)
other skills?
How do we use a book.
speed: reading, writing, typing, looking up references, finding things
reading
printed book
flexible in where to use
easy to read sequentially
electronic book
requires computer equipment to use
not as flexible in where to use
not as comfortable to read sequentially
The electronic book requires a computer and other
peripherals, such as a monitor and a CD-ROM so that usage costs are
higher and flexibility of usage is restricted.
This is less of a factor if computers are amortized over
other usage, and if notebook computers are used for travel access.
There is a weight trade-off for large books: 1 million pages
= 0.5 million sheets of paper vs. notebook computer plus CD-ROM
player plus CD-ROMs.
searching for information
printed book
it is fairly easy to find specific information that is listed in an index or TOC - by looking up pages
it is very difficult to find specific information that is not listed in an index or TOC
it is fairly difficult to follow a reference to another book
electronic book
The main advantage of electronic books is that they let users "bounce around" in the book easily. There are three main methods of navigation. First, the table of contents and the index work like menus, so that one can jump directly to the content. Second, one can also jump directly from a references to the text being referred to. Third, all of the content is indexed automatically so that one can search for words or phrases and then step to the places where they occur.
it is easy to find specific information that is listed in an index or TOC by following an electronic link
it is very easy to find specific information that is not listed in an index or TOC by starting a search, obtaining a list of places where the information is found, and finding the information which has been highlighted.
Powerful search capabilities give more flexibility
for information retrieval, since the search does not have to be preconceived
and structured in with a TOC or index. The search is structured at
the time of use and is individualized for the user.
reference: it is very easy to follow a reference to another book by following an electronic link
The electronic book may allow for personal profiling
for faster access to frequently used information.
sharing & interacting with other readers
printed book
it is difficult to share the content with another user simultaneously & interact about the content
electronic book
it is fairly easy to share the content with another user simultaneously & interact about the content (via modem or on a LAN)
responding to & interacting with the author
printed book
it is very difficult to respond to the author about the content
it is nearly impossible to interact with the author
electronic book
response: it is easy to respond to the author about the content (with E-Mail)
interact: it is possible to interact with the author (on a Bulleting Board, or via E-Mail)
annotating & editing
printed book
it is slightly awkward to annotate & edit the content for private use
it is difficult to share annotations with others & jointly edit the content for group use (e.g., model agreements)
electronic book
Users may mark up the text by leaving bookmarks, highlighting the text, or adding annotations. Inserting or extracting text from or to a word processing package such as WordPerfect is straightforward.
it is easy to annotate & edit the content - by inserting notes or by attaching files
it is easy to share & jointly edit
re-using the material in the book
printed book
re-use: it is awkward and difficult to reuse the content, even if permitted
electronic book
re-use: it is fairly easy to reuse the content, if permitted, by extracting the text into a file
The electronic book provides more support for
information re-use, by allowing selective retrieval of information
in printed or in file formats. This information may be integrated
into other applications that require the information.
skill levels required for usage
printed book
Basic literacy skills of reading in the appropriate language is sufficient for many books
Some books may require background information for comprehension
Some books, e.g., mathematics, may require literacy in language extensions, e.g., reading equations, maps and schematics, etc.
Basic writing skills are required for annotating and editing
electronic book